Episode 610

Footlong Fear: Men Ordering Like It’s a First Date

Published on: 17th November, 2026

Hot take: I think restaurants are secretly losing cash because hot employees make dudes under-order. I was talking with a buddy who walked into a sandwich shop ready to bankrupt the place, then saw the girl behind the counter and suddenly ordered a sad six-inch, no chips, no cookie, water only. We riff on how insecure men will literally starve themselves to impress a stranger who’s just asking “toasted?” — and how that might be leaving thousands of dollars on the table. I even cooked up the “Instant Insecurity Diet” — no meds, no workouts, just crippling fear of being judged while ordering extra cheese. We poke fun at the idea franchises could blame falling lunch sales on three guys asking if Tiffany’s single. It’s all silly, obvious, and one more reason I’ll keep telling dudes to order the brownie.

Takeaways:

  • I tell about a buddy who's convinced restaurants lose money because insecure dudes under-order in front of gorgeous employees.
  • We laugh at guys pretending to eat Victorian-style tiny meals, forgetting the cashier just wants to know six inches or a foot long.
  • I pitch the 'Instant Insecurity Diet' as a joke — it makes dudes eat less by weaponizing their own self-esteem, complete with awkward small talk side effects.
  • Restaurants, take note: this dumb human behavior might be an overlooked profit leak, not just food or labor costs, so maybe rethink your sales strategy.
  • And hey, if you're starving yourself to impress a server who doesn't even know your name, congrats — you're doing marriage practice early.
Transcript
Speaker A:

It taste dak.

Speaker A:

And I was having a conversation over the weekend with one of my best friends, and I think he may have uncovered a major problem in the restaurant industry.

Speaker A:

So if you are in restaurant owner or operator, listen up.

Speaker A:

Going to unlock some more profit for you.

Speaker A:

I don't, I don't think anyone is talking about this.

Speaker A:

You see, restaurants worry about food cost, labor costs.

Speaker A:

All these places, they've got to try to control expenses.

Speaker A:

But here's the thing.

Speaker A:

Costing them more money than anything.

Speaker A:

Really attractive employees are costing them money.

Speaker A:

Now, before you get upset, hear me out.

Speaker A:

This, this is not the, the attractive employee's fault.

Speaker A:

This is because men are idiots.

Speaker A:

My buddy goes into a sandwich shop.

Speaker A:

He's hungry.

Speaker A:

He knew exactly what he wanted.

Speaker A:

He was ready to order enough food to keep that place in business through Christmas.

Speaker A:

But he gets to the counter, and the woman taking his order is absolutely gorgeous.

Speaker A:

And suddenly this man develops portion control, starts thinking, well, I, I can't order everything I actually want.

Speaker A:

She's gonna think I'm a fat ass.

Speaker A:

Dude, you are.

Speaker A:

She doesn't know you.

Speaker A:

She's not evaluating you as a potential mate.

Speaker A:

She's asking if you want 6 inches or a foot long.

Speaker A:

And this allegedly adult full grown man is standing there trying to make a good impression by pretending he eats like some Victorian school.

Speaker A:

Oh, just the small sandwich, please.

Speaker A:

No chips, no cookie.

Speaker A:

Water will be fine.

Speaker A:

Thank you.

Speaker A:

Meanwhile, his stomach is screaming, what the hell are we doing?

Speaker A:

And here's the part that kills me.

Speaker A:

He genuinely said the restaurant lost money because of this.

Speaker A:

He's convinced that across America, restaurants are leaving thousands of dollars on the table because insecure men will not order extra cheese in front of a pretty woman.

Speaker A:

Ed, I, I can't say he's wrong.

Speaker A:

I'm ashamed to admit it, but I've done that before where I was like, oh, I'm going to get that.

Speaker A:

And that, you know, maybe I'll.

Speaker A:

Maybe I'll back.

Speaker A:

Imagine explaining that, though, to a franchise owner.

Speaker A:

Well, sir, our lunch sales are down 12%.

Speaker A:

But on the bright side, three customers asked Tiffany if she's single.

Speaker A:

The woman behind the counter could not care less.

Speaker A:

She's got a dozen orders to fill.

Speaker A:

She just wants to know if you want the sandwich toasted.

Speaker A:

Order cookie.

Speaker A:

Man, she was not gonna date you anyway.

Speaker A:

I mean, buddy, if you're willing to go hungry just to impress a woman who does not know your name.

Speaker A:

You know, come to think of it, congratulations.

Speaker A:

You've already got the worst part of marriage figured out.

Speaker A:

Guys, are you tired of Diets that don't work.

Speaker A:

Sick of counting calories?

Speaker A:

Spending a fortune on weight loss programs?

Speaker A:

Well, forget Ozempic, forget Weight Watchers.

Speaker A:

Introducing the Instant Insecurity Diet.

Speaker B:

It's the revolutionary new weight loss program that uses own pathetic self esteem to make you eat less.

Speaker A:

Restaurants like Hooters, Twin Peaks and Walk Ons have spent years using attractive women to get men through the door.

Speaker A:

But they've been doing it all wrong.

Speaker A:

The secret isn't a beautiful woman that you expect to see.

Speaker A:

It's the beautiful woman you never saw coming.

Speaker A:

You're a hungry, slightly overweight guy walking into a sandwich shop.

Speaker A:

You're ready for a footlong double beat, extra cheese, chips and two cookies.

Speaker A:

But wait, the woman behind the counter is gorgeous.

Speaker A:

Suddenly you're not hungry anymore.

Speaker C:

I'll just have the six inch turkey.

Speaker C:

No cheese, no chips, just water.

Speaker A:

Amazing.

Speaker A:

You've eliminated:

Speaker C:

I was gonna get a brownie, but I didn't want her to think I was a fat ass.

Speaker A:

With the Instant Insecurity Diet, there's no exercise, no calorie counting, no expensive medications.

Speaker A:

Just the crippling fear that a complete stranger might judge your lunch order.

Speaker B:

Side effects may include awkward small talk, excessive sweating, pretending to enjoy salads, and eating an entire frozen pizza alone when you get home.

Speaker A:

The Instant Insecurity Diet.

Speaker A:

Because nothing kills an appetite faster than the possibility of being rejected by a woman who wasn't interested in the first place.

Next Episode All Episodes Previous Episode
Show artwork for Haysnacks

About the Podcast

Haysnacks
Quick Bites. Big Laughs. You'll Want Seconds!
Enjoy Haysnacks, the bite-sized comedy podcast from Northwest Arkansas’s own Haystack—morning radio’s master of mischief on 106.5 KBVA and 96.7 The Bull. Each episode packs in the best moments from Haystack’s daily shows, including fan-favorite highlights, his legendary “morning six pack” top 6 lists, and the hilarious weekly phone call with his super-redneck pal, Alabama Bama. Don’t miss the Saturday “Leftovers” episode, where Haystack serves up the jokes and bits that didn’t make it on air (due to time, or because they were too weird or wild). Designed for busy listeners, Haysnacks delivers quick, snackable laughs whenever you need them—perfect for your commute, coffee break, or anytime you want a dose of fun.

About your host

Profile picture for Mark Wells

Mark Wells